Buried
Movie Review
"Buried"
Review by Eric D. Snider
Grade: B
Rating: R
Released: Friday, September 24, 2010
Directed by:
Cast:
To set your film entirely in one room is to risk being visually boring. How do you avoid stagnation when there's a limited number of different angles to shoot from? Usually we're obliged to focus on the story and dialogue and accept that there won't be much to stimulate the eyes. When a filmmaker finds a way to keep it fresh in spite of the claustrophobia -- like Sidney Lumet did in the jury room of "Twelve Angry Men" -- it's noteworthy.
So major kudos are in order for Spanish director Rodrigo Cortés, whose second feature, "Buried," is set in a coffin -- about as small a location as you could have for a movie about a normal-sized human. Yet Cortés and his cinematographer, Eduard Grau (who also did outstanding work on "A Single Man"), find an impressive number of ways to keep things fresh without resorting to gimmicks or tricks. It's sheer technical skill at play here.
The coffin is occupied by Ryan Reynolds, essentially the only actor in the film and deserving of praise for holding our attention single-handedly. Not everyone can do that. He plays Paul Conroy, a civilian contractor in Iraq who was driving a supply truck when insurgents attacked and he lost consciousness. Now he wakes up in a coffin -- a fairly roomy one, as coffins go, but a coffin nonetheless -- apparently buried in the ground. He has a cigarette lighter, a pen, and a cell phone with him, the latter provided by his abductors, who use it to contact him and give him their ransom instructions.
And that's basically it. To say more about the story -- indeed, to say whether there even IS more to the story -- would be unfair. Without giving anything away, I can report that the film stays on the road of the mostly plausible. If you can accept the outstanding cell phone reception Paul gets underground (he's probably only a couple feet down) and the unlimited oxygen supply, the rest of what transpires is, pardon the expression, down to earth: no supernatural elements, no outrageous plot twists.
Now, whether that's good or bad is a matter of opinion. I appreciate that the film takes the scenario of being buried alive and lets it play out logically, but part of me thinks the movie (which was written by Chris Sparling) might have been more satisfying if it had taken a more imaginative route -- if it had been a little less realistic, in other words. When it's done, you think, "That's it?" But then you think, "Well, but what else COULD have happened?" This might be as good a movie as could have been made with this premise.
I can't overstate the film's technical merits -- the camera angles, the lighting, the editing, the musical score, they all contribute to boosting the energy and suspense of what could easily have been a dull 90 minutes. Reynolds expertly conveys the frustration, fear, and anger of the situation, keeping us with him every step of the way. You probably have never seen a movie like this before, and if it's not completely successful at least it makes a respectably entertaining attempt.
Grade: B
Rated R, some harsh profanity, brief strong violence
1 hr., 34 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.



This item has 6 comments
September 29, 2010 at 1:48 am
Shouldn't he have been found fairly easily/quickly using the GPS features of literally every cell phone made in recent years?
Especially since agencies like law enforcement and the military can get access to that data without issue.
That was my main concern when I saw the preview.
September 29, 2010 at 11:09 am
Russ: Believe it or not, the 90-minute movie actually goes into more detail and explains more things than the two-minute trailer does.
October 1, 2010 at 12:00 am
Guess it was a stupid question, but I never trust Hollywood when it comes to writing something smart.
Should have put more trust in your grade though, there have been a lot of B's recently, not too many terrible movies this Fall so far!
October 1, 2010 at 5:45 pm
Nice joke. It's funny because D***-in-a-box is a popular SNL digital short, and because Ryan Reynolds is normally cast as a d***-type character. Ha!
October 1, 2010 at 8:14 pm
So, would you recommend this movie for someone who is claustrophobic to the point that the review is making her have trouble breathing? After reading this, I'd really like to see the performance, but having a panic attack in the theater would probably be inconsiderate to everyone else. (My husband has just told me that our stifled laughs and whispered heckling during the Twilight movies is probably not very considerate, yet we're willing to do that. The difference here is that I care about this movie.)
Hmmmm. Maybe video...and I'll watch it outside.
October 4, 2010 at 9:54 pm
Huh, I was expecting you to compare the movie to "Phone Booth." Are they not that similar? I went back and checked and you actually gave both movies the same grade. So far I can guess that the major difference is that this movie doesn't even cut away from the coffin for a single scene, and no one else is ever shown. Is that fair?