If you combined "The Karate Kid" with "Fight Club," then threw in a dash of "The O.C." and "You Got Served," then beat it with a stick until it was really stupid, you'd have something twice as smart as "Never Back Down." The very height of teen-oriented idiocy, this wrong-headed ode to violence is aimed at two particular niches: vapid girls who want to watch sweaty, shirtless young men fight each other; and meathead guys who believe macho douchebaggery is the answer to all life's problems (and who also, incidentally, want to watch sweaty, shirtless young men fight each other).
Our Daniel-san is the brooding, hotheaded Jake Tyler (Sean Faris), a young-Tom-Cruise-looking high schooler who has just moved with his beleaguered mother (Leslie Hope) and idolizing little brother (Wyatt Smith) from Iowa to Florida. A couple half-hearted references are made to the local kids' wealth versus the Tyler family's poverty, I guess to remind us that Jake is supposed to be an "outsider" despite being bright, athletic, and startlingly handsome.
His new school has an underground fight club, and the number one rule of this fight club is to tell everyone about it. Led by top fighter Ryan McCarthy (Cam Gigandet), whose prowess makes him even more important on campus than the football or basketball players, the fighters call it "brawling." It's more than just throwing punches: It's full-on, no-holds-barred, Ultimate Fighting Championship stuff, known officially as "mixed martial arts."
Ryan sees a YouTube video of Jake getting into a fight after a football game at his old school, and for some reason this means Ryan must force Jake to fight him. To that end, Ryan has his girlfriend, Baja (Amber Heard), flirt with Jake and invite him to a house party. Thus lured in to the dragon's lair, Jake initially resists brawling with Ryan, even though Ryan is friendly about it. "I saw the clip, and you can bang, dude!" he says, with as much vague homoeroticism as everything else in the movie (i.e., a lot of it). Unmoved, Jake won't fight until finally Ryan taunts him into it, whereupon he totally kicks Jake's butt.
After that humiliation, Jake's new sidekick, Max (Evan Peters) -- kind of dorky and much less handsome, as mandated by Movie Sidekick bylaws -- tells Jake about a mixed-martial-arts training facility run by Mr. Miyagi, who is strangely using the pseudonym Jean Roqua and being played by Djimon Hounsou. Jake goes there to learn how to brawl better so he can get revenge on Ryan. Despite being a novice at the mixed combat style, he demands to be put in the advanced class, and for some reason Roqua agrees to his demands.
I find myself using the phrase "for some reason" a lot as I try to explain what happens in this movie. For some reason Jake's mother gets angry when she learns Jake is training with Roqua, even though this is healthy, disciplined fighting, not the fisticuffs he used to get into regularly in Iowa. For some reason Baja -- now actually growing fond of Jake -- is really mad that Jake won't accept her apology for setting him up at the party, like somehow HE'S the jerk here. For some reason the finale has a nightclub willing to host a major brawl tournament, even though such an event would be a huge insurance liability (and probably illegal besides).
Oh, yeah. The finale. The big brawl tournament is called The Beatdown, and it's super-secret and no one knows when or where it's taking place until they get a text message 24 hours in advance ... and then it turns out to be at this very popular club where hundreds of people are dancing anyway. So I guess stealth wasn't really a key component after all.
By this time, Jake has realized that he doesn't need to fight Ryan to feel good about himself, and that it wouldn't solve anything anyway. Thank goodness that feeling passes! Instead, he lets Ryan goad him into fighting again, even indicating he's aware he's being manipulated but dismissing it when Baja calls him on it. "Walking away and giving up are not the same thing," she says. "Good," he replies. "Because I'm not doing either one." But if he's not doing either one, then why is it "good" that they're not the same thing? Their differentness is irrelevant in that case. He should have said, "That's fine, but I'm not doing either one anyway." Proper syntax is important, Jake.
The screenplay (by Chris Hauty, whose only other IMDb credit was 12 years ago) is written in such a way as to maximize its impact on horny, volatile 18-year-old boys. The characters call each other "bro" and "dude" almost exclusively and taunt each other with sexual euphemisms like "faggot," "bitch," and the multiple-entendre "let's get it on." Director Jeff Wadlow ("Cry_Wolf") fills the party scenes with boobful girls, at one point showing a couple of them making out in a hot tub pretty much just so guys in the audience will hoot.
I guess we're into spoiler territory here, but I want to tell you what the film's message is. The film's message is that sometimes -- heck, MOST of the time -- fighting is the answer. You might think it would be unwise for Jake to fight Ryan again. You might think it will only lead to more escalation, that if Jake beats Ryan it will make Ryan want to come back and beat Jake, and back and forth like that forever. But that is WRONG, amigos. The fact is, if you respond to your notoriously unstable arch-rival's tauntings by beating the crap out of him in front of the whole town, AND you steal his girlfriend -- well, after that he'll never try to fight you again. The next day at school he'll nod and smile at you, because now he RESPECTS you.
See? Aren't you glad you fought him? You settled it once and for all! Good thing you ignored Mr. Miyagi and your mother and your girlfriend and everything else you ever learned. Never back down, bro!
Grade: D
Rated PG-13, moderate profanity, a little mild sexuality, lots of underage drinking and partying
1 hr., 50 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.
This item has 11 comments
March 14, 2008 at 12:43 am
It's good to know that finally some movies are giving teens good morals.
March 14, 2008 at 5:31 am
As a fan of mixed martial arts, the sound of this movie annoys me. MMA groups have worked hard to earn the respect they deserve. It's safer than boxing, but for some reason people like McCain want to compare it to human cock-fighting. Then a movie like this comes out where it's got secret fighting arenas and it's just where people fight to show how cool/bad they are. I don't think the audience they were going for will enjoy this movie.
March 14, 2008 at 9:17 am
My only consolation for the horrendous quality of so many movies nowadays is that I get to giggle through Eric's awesome reviews. The negative ones are so much more fun than the positive ones. Carry on with your awfulness, Hollywood!
Why is everyone listed twice in your little beige box?
Also, "nowadays?" I said nowadays? Yes, because apparently I'm 70. Get off my lawn you darn kids!
March 16, 2008 at 5:20 pm
I don't think the audience they were going for will enjoy this movie.
You mean horny teenagers? I see no reason why they wouldn't enjoy this movie. Apparently two girls with big breasts make out in a swimming pool at some point, and I don't understand why a movie like that wouldn't be a hit with that audience.
March 18, 2008 at 4:55 am
But the movie didn't get an F, so it must have some redeeming value...
but what?
March 20, 2008 at 3:25 am
Great review Eric. I love the line about the first rule of this fight club is to tell everyone about it. I have to say that you don't have to worry about spoilers though. If someone couldn't see exactly what was coming the whole way through, they aren't smart enough to even find your review. I want to play the for some reason game. For some reason, the mom was fine with him fighting the final battle at the end because he was wearing his dad's shirt. For some reason, the amazingly hot girlfriend was nothing before she dated the villain and "walked the halls like a ghost". Honestly is there a school in the world where either Faris or Heard would be outcasts and unpopular.
March 21, 2008 at 9:55 am
I laughed out loud man... I wasn't going to watch it anyway but I felt like reading your review and that is just too funny.
March 21, 2008 at 7:47 pm
Man, this movie really does sound like a blatant ripoff of the Karate Kid. Except several thousand times less awesome. Strike first. Strike hard. No mercy.
March 25, 2008 at 7:47 am
Honestly, based on the original review, why did this person give it two stars? It, based only on the trailers would get NO stars from me.
April 1, 2008 at 11:27 am
i saw it and it wasn't horrible, i actually kind of liked it! i do agree with your review for the most part though.
mostly, i think i liked it because of the sweaty guys and holy [swear word] cam had the best body i've ever seen. i give it 5 stars just for that! :)
April 14, 2008 at 11:36 pm
OMG!!!!
MY new favourite movie the music the fight were so good, the drama the whole girlfriend thing a bit predictable but you know it was a cute story. it was a good show of what happens in the streets and i don't care what anyone says i loved it!!!
and i loved the guys in it aswell...