Eric D. Snider

Contagion

Movie Review

"Contagion"

Review by Eric D. Snider

Grade: B

Rating: PG-13

Released: Friday, September 9, 2011

Directed by:

Cast:

Many horror films use scary sounds to unnerve us, and "Contagion" -- a horror film disguised as a medical thriller -- is no exception. As the film begins, before we even see anything, we hear a cough. An ordinary-sounding cough, maybe. But it's rather ominous when it's the first sound in a movie called "Contagion."

Steven Soderbergh directed it, his first feature since 2009's larkish "The Informant!" He's back to his no-nonsense approach now, determined to alarm and entertain in equal measure. The huge cast of characters and the global story covered from multiple angles hearken back to "Traffic"; like that film, "Contagion" is startlingly realistic and immaculately assembled, but lacking in heart.

The premise is simple and eerie. What if a new deadly infectious disease sprang up? How would the world's governments react? How would ordinary citizens react? How many people would die before a vaccine could be produced? How long will you want to wash your hands after seeing this movie, especially considering movie theaters are the filthiest places on Earth? (Going to a movie theater to watch a film about germs is like going to a public library to read a book about homeless people.)

Our entry point to the story is a businesswoman, played by Gwyneth Paltrow, who returns to Minnesota from a trip to Hong Kong with basic flu-like symptoms that quickly escalate into something worse. It's contagious, too, which is pretty bad news. Her husband (Matt Damon) and stepdaughter (Anna Jacoby-Heron) are the film's constants after that, but the story expands to address almost every conceivable aspect of the epidemic. At the Centers for Disease Control, Laurence Fishburne heads up the effort to identify and treat the virus, with Demetri Martin and Jennifer Ehle testing vaccines as they are formulated. The CDC's Kate Winslet goes to Minnesota to investigate and is met with resistance by the state's health department, mostly because of budgetary concerns and the sense that we've had false alarms before. (The recent H1N1 non-epidemic is mentioned.) The World Health Organization's Marion Cotillard goes to Hong Kong to track down the disease's origins.

Meanwhile, it is spreading. As more days go by without a vaccine, people begin to panic, hoard, and loot. Jude Law turns up as a muckraking blogger and conspiracy theorist pushing a holistic cure that he says the government doesn't want you to know about; Elliott Gould plays a scientist assisting the CDC; there's Bryan Cranston as a U.S. military official, Enrico Colantoni as a government official, many people with less recognizable names and faces playing a host of other necessary figures.

Through it all, Soderbergh keeps us nervous with constant, subtle reminders of where the danger lurks, i.e., everywhere. A bowl of peanuts at a bar, a credit card passed to a cashier, the door handle in a public building -- everything is a potential threat, and Soderbergh (who serves as his own cinematographer) lingers over such images just long enough to make his point.

What's scariest about "Contagion" is that every part of it could really happen. No suspension of disbelief is required here. Furthermore, while there are well-known protections against vampires and zombies (and easy ways to tell if somebody is one), the only way to avoid a deadly virus is to avoid all human contact. We must also grapple with the fact that if an outbreak like this occurred in real life, there would indeed be people seeking to cash in on it, and bureaucratic inefficiency causing delays, and fearmongers giving counterproductive advice. People would rely on the government to help them while simultaneously not trusting it to do so. In short, "Contagion" is effective because it plays not on our fears of fictional boogeymen and monsters, but on actual threats.

It's far less effective when it tries to show the human side of things. The largely plot-driven screenplay, by Scott Z. Burns (who adapted "The Informant!"), makes an effort now and then to engage our emotions, but it seldom succeeds. Moments like Laurence Fishburne interacting with a lowly CDC janitor (John Hawkes) come off as trite, while Matt Damon's efforts to protect his daughter don't register as anything more than perfunctory. Some films have managed to tell a global story while maintaining an emotional center, but this isn't one of them. Maybe it's just as well, though. You don't want to get attached to people in a movie that will make you never want to touch anyone again.

Grade: B

Rated PG-13, one F-word, moderate profanity, some grisly images, mild violence

1 hr., 45 min.

Digg! Stumble It!

This item has 11 comments

  1. Damen Stephens says:

    I can't trust the blog of anyone who believes homeless people are abundantly found inn public libraries or that zombies and vampires are "fictional".

  2. Dustin Fife says:

    I am a county library Director. Homeless people can only be found in greater numbers than in libraries in public parks and Barnes and Noble. We literally have state wide meetings about this issue. I love them. I'm always fighting for homeless library rights.

  3. Huston says:

    "fearmongers giving counterproductive advice"

    Global viral outbreak? Buy gold!

  4. Ryan says:

    Eric, please tell me that you laughed out loud at using "Demetri Martin" and "testing vaccines" in the same sentence. I looked at it for like two minutes, chuckling softly though audibly.

  5. Lauren says:

    Agree with Ryan. Seriously though what the hell was Demitri Martin doing in this movie? He was a distracting miscast for me.

  6. Charly says:

    Holy star-studded, Batman! Comedy Central standup AND Lizzie Bennett? The stars of "GATTACA" and "Inception"?! Wow.

  7. Diane says:

    I work in public health and enjoyed a lot of aspects of this movie. Maybe I’ll take the next epidemiological investigation training a little more seriously. During the last one, only one person opted for the full gear suit to interview patients. The rest of us were worried we would panic people. Panic vs. death? Maybe panic isn’t such a bad thing.

  8. Ed says:

    I used to spend a lot of time in public Libraries AND B&N after having huge fights with my 1st wife. I guess that sort of made me temporarily homeless.

    These days I read at home. Safe from ANY virus! I don't believe I've been in a library in 8 years....THANK GOD!

  9. Bobby Dee says:

    The character of Matt Damon's daughter is his full daughter, not his stepdaughter. In her first scene Damon tells her she should be at her mom's in another state but she indicates that she's staying with him.

  10. Eric D. Snider says:

    #8: That's what the review says. She's Gwyneth Paltrow's stepdaughter, Matt Damon's daughter.

  11. Nate says:

    I thought the movie had just the right amount of heart. Lots of little things like Kate Winslet giving her coat to the cold guy even though she was dying, Matt Damon hiding his emotions from his daughter. Effective but not trying to overshadow the plot of virus outbreak.

    @ Eric and Bobby Dee: Speaking of daughter, I could have sworn that the girl was Matt Damon's stepdaughter. I remember clearly that he told her to go stay with her DAD in Wisconsin, not her mom. One of us is hallucinating. It's probably me. But I'm not going to re-watch the film just to figure this out.

Add your comment:

The following HTML elements are allowed: <span class="spoiler">content</span>, <strong>, <em>, <a>, and <img>.

Before posting, please read the rules.


Subscription Center

Eric D. Snider's "Snide Remarks"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly humor column, "Snide Remarks." For more information, go here.

Subscribe

Eric D. Snider's "In the Dark"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly movie-review e-zine. For more information on it, go here.

Subscribe
 
Come read about baseball and web development at www.jeffjsnider.com