Doom
Movie Review
"Doom"
Review by Eric D. Snider
Grade: D
Rating: R
Released: Friday, October 21, 2005
Directed by:
Cast:
In almost 100 years of history, Hollywood has rarely produced a series of films as consistent as those based on video games: A dozen of them now, and not one has been any good. Not one! (Don't bother naming one and saying, "What about that one?!," because the answer is no; it sucked.)
The latest is "Doom," a loud and bloody big-screen adaptation of the game that popularized the "first-person shooter" genre, where the action is seen through the player's eyes rather than from an omniscient perspective. In homage to its roots, "Doom" the movie has a few minutes of first-person killing near the end, the camera acting as a character's eyes as he goes around shooting everything -- but since we can't control him like we can at home, the effect is like watching passively while someone else plays a video game. And where's the fun in that?
Nowhere, that's where. In fact, what fun there is in "Doom" is only at the film's expense, laughing at its flimsy story and its goofy pseudo-scientific dialogue. ("Ten percent of the human genome is still unmapped," says a scientist. "Some say it's the blueprint for the soul." Heavy, man.)
The deal is that 40 years hence, a scientific research laboratory on Mars has been besieged by mysterious and sinister forces. A team of U.S. Marines back here in the good ol' U.S. of Earth is sent to rescue the six doctors and scientists, but when they arrive they find: MONSTERS! Vicious beasts the size of very large humans with oversized, agile tongues! What's a team of Marines to do but find giant guns and fire them repeatedly?
The bulk of the film is set in the dimly lit cement-gray and steel-black corridors of the Mars lab, a reminder of the "Alien" films, which used silent, claustrophobic settings like these to create fear. "Doom" uses them to create violence. Mistaking fear and violence for each other is a common error among incompetent filmmakers. (In this case it is Andrzej Bartkowiak, whose senseless but stylish action flicks "Romeo Must Die" and "Cradle 2 the Grave" hardly suggested how crappy "Doom" would turn out.)
Oh right, the characters. I forgot there were characters. Well, there's Pretty Scientist (Rosamund Pike), whose bickersome brother (Karl Urban) is among the Marines sent to rescue her team. There's the Young Recruit (Al Weaver) who is eager and idealistic and will surely die on this, his first mission. There's the slimy and perverted Horndog Marine (Richard Brake). And then there are several others with no distinguishing characteristics except, in some cases, their race.
And then there's The Rock, who plays the Marine squad leader. The Rock has pleasantly surprised a lot of people with his acting, which has often been entertaining and even laudable. Those of us who didn't like having to respect him as an actor, who don't like taking men seriously who are professional wrestlers and don't have real names -- we breathe a sigh of relief with "Doom," where The Rock at last lives up to his potential as a hilariously bad actor.
Do this with me. Make your eyes really big and angry, exaggeratedly so, like a cartoon. Then over-enunciate every word as you loudly bark an order to an inferior. (Try: "I need copies of this report NOW!" or "I want you to take out the trash!") That's The Rock. Remember Jack Nicholson's delivery on "You can't handle the truth!" in "A Few Good Men"? That's The Rock on every single line in "Doom."
The screenplay, by David Callaham and Wesley Strick ("Arachnophobia," "The Saint"), is strictly serviceable, nothing fancy. Yet it has curiously long stretches where it tries to BE fancy, eschewing shoot-em-up shenanigans so it can ramble on and on about the "science" behind the monsters. That's a fine thing to do if you've got creative ideas and good actors to convey them, but when you're bankrupt in both categories, maybe it's best to shut up and get back to shooting. At least that has a certain visceral thrill, for a few minutes, anyway.
Grade: D
Rated R, abundant harsh profanity, a lot of violence and gore
1 hr., 40 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.



This item has 6 comments
February 9, 2007 at 9:05 pm
I just got tricked into seeing this movie, and man, D is being generous. The entire movie felt like guys running down dimly lit hallways yelling swear words. The Rock was the best part for me, because I'd at least stay awake when he was yelling stuff. Terrible.
February 9, 2007 at 11:46 pm
Yeah, Eric's right. Sometimes I don't agree with him about video game movies (while they're not great, they are enjoyable) but this one wasn't. It was ok in the beginning, but then the writers knew they wanted something to happen, so it just happened, apropos of nothing and that's when it really started to suck. I can't explain it more than that...stuff just..happens..and it makes no sense.
February 13, 2007 at 3:40 pm
U.S. of Earth. That amuses me.
March 10, 2007 at 8:37 pm
Just watched this on DVD last night. I'd totally agree with this review. All in all, this movie ended up being laughably bad, especially with The Rock stuck in Single Facial Expression mode. Oh, wait, he tried to cock his eyebrow once.
Also, replace all the swear words with "ass" and the dialogue is comedy gold.
April 16, 2008 at 11:18 pm
The worst thing about this movie was the story. Doom itself had a equally simple story, but the movie dumped it in, why? what's the point? is opening a doorway to hell that unleashes demons on mars with only 1 soldier to fight them to difficult to work a screen play around that they had to change it?
Such a let down, like all the other video game transitions to the big screen. Why couldn't they have just ripped off Aliens and been done with it.
May 10, 2008 at 2:17 pm
I went to this movie thinking this is going to be good, I mean Event Horizon felt almost like Doom, with all the hell influences on a ship.. but no, I walked away let-down. I didn't go to see the FPS scene in fact I felt embarressed watching it, after how pathetic the movie was.
There was no mention of demons, instead I had to watch a movie which tried to be Resident Evil and still failed miserably. What is so bad about a portal swarming a base with demons? In Event Horizon a ship expriences hell while traversing between two points in space. Here there was no mention of it. Why did a guy in a wheelchair who didn't seem to be bad in anyway turn into what he turned into?
People don't realise that many gamers are very critical about movies made from games, we want good acting and a good story, not this.. this drivel. The one time I saw the BFG used, it was used on a wall! A Wall?! What is the point of that?
When making this movie they could have at least tried.