Enchanted
Movie Review
"Enchanted"
Review by Eric D. Snider
Grade: B+
Rating: PG
Released: Wednesday, November 21, 2007
Directed by:
Cast:
"Enchanted" isn't a perfect Disney film, but it's the closest thing to a live-action classic that the studio has produced in a very long time. Most of the Mouse House's recent films have been minor trifles like "The Pacifier" or "Underdog," comparable to the fondly remembered but not particularly good '60s and '70s goofs like "The Computer Wore Tennis Shoes" and "The Barefoot Executive." "Enchanted" is more on the order of "Mary Poppins": magical, endearing, funny to both kids and adults, and featuring a star-making performance.
That would be Amy Adams, already an Oscar nominee and winner of many critic groups' awards for "Junebug," which not enough people saw. "Enchanted" should be her mainstream breakout. She plays Giselle, a cartoon fairy-tale girl cut from the same cloth as old-school heroines like Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty. She's interested primarily in meeting a handsome prince who will sweep her off her feet and marry her immediately. She meets the guy, Prince Edward (James Marsden), but before they can wed his wicked stepmother, Queen Narissa (Susan Sarandon), pushes her into a wishing well that sends her into another dimension -- the third.
The movie has been animated up to this point; now it is live-action, with Giselle in flesh and blood in New York City, completely baffled and frightened by the real world. Where is the castle? Where are the handsome princes to catch her when she falls? Why does the midget she runs into not answer to the name Grumpy?
She is rescued from the rain by a Good Samaritan named Robert (Patrick Dempsey). He's a divorce lawyer who views romance from a practical standpoint. He and his girlfriend, Nancy (Idina Menzel), have been dating for five years, and he's just now thinking of proposing. He has a 6-year-old daughter, Morgan (Rachel Covey), who loves fairy-tale princesses. Dad bought her a book of biographies of historical women instead.
They let Giselle sleep on their couch, stymied by her naive behavior and concerned for her safety if she's allowed to wander the streets. (She was planning to sleep "in a nearby meadow, or a hollow tree.") She's waiting for Prince Edward to come rescue her -- which, in fact, he's trying to do, having cast himself into the same wishing well, popping up out of the same New York manhole. Joining him are Giselle's chipmunk friend Pip (who cannot talk in the real world like he can in cartoonland) and a royal adviser named Nathaniel (Timothy Spall), who secretly works for the evil Queen and is trying to kill Giselle.
Many delights follow. The screenplay, by Bill Kelly ("Premonition"), is rife with references to classic Disney cartoons, some subtle and some not. I absolutely adore the scene where Giselle summons her animal friends to help her clean up Robert's apartment -- which, since it's New York, turn out to be rats, pigeons, and cockroaches. ("Well, it's always nice to make new friends!") What's more, she sings a song while she does it, with clever lyrics mentioning the words "toilet," "hairball," and "vermin." (I heartily recommend watching the clip of this scene at the film's MySpace page. It's called "Happy Working Song.")
As Robert guides Giselle around the city, looking for Edward, they teach each other a thing or two. He learns to be a little more romantic and spontaneous, while she learns about this thing called "dating," where the prince and princess actually get to know one another before getting married. In her world, of course, all the prince has to do is wake someone up or put someone's shoe on, and bam! They're married the next day.
Essentially, Giselle evolves from an old-school character like Cinderella (who really didn't have a lot of depth) to a modern heroine like Belle (who did). And while this isn't the kind of movie that gets nominated for acting Oscars, Amy Adams' performance is one of the most completely convincing of any movie this year. She has the walk, the voice, and the gestures of a cartoon heroine -- and then somehow, on top of all that, makes her believable as a person, too. "Enchanted" is a rather generic title for this movie, but you can see why it stuck. Adams is absolutely enchanting.
Prince Edward is also a lot of fun as he jaunts around Manhattan in search of his bride-to-be, calling out to her in song when he spots her, just in time to be run over by a bicyclist. The character gently satirizes the blandness and vanity of fairy-tale princes. When Pip does charades to try to get Edward to understand Narissa's evil plan, Edward's guesses are along the lines of "You can't believe how handsome I am?" and "You're honored to be in my presence?"
Susan Sarandon only gets a few minutes of live-action evil, but she appears to be having a blast camping it up. Unfortunately, her subplot with Nathaniel isn't developed very well, nor is her motivation for wanting Giselle dead exactly clear. (If Edward marries, somehow that means his bride becomes queen and Narissa is dethroned?) I'm also disappointed by the short shrift given to some of the secondary characters, whose happily-ever-after endings don't quite add up. The presence of a cheap fart joke and a cheap poop joke doesn't exactly thrill me, either. I guess no matter how otherwise smart and respectable a kids movie is, if it's Disney, it's gotta have flatulence.
But overall, director Kevin Lima ("Tarzan," "102 Dalmatians") does a fantastic job with the film's many-layered story and subtle homages, never letting the references become strained or obvious. He focuses on the story, like he ought to, and generally avoids pandering to the young audience. Classic Disney actresses Julie Andrews (Mary Poppins), Paige O'Hara (Belle), Judy Kuhn (Pocahontas' singing voice), and Jodi Benson (Ariel) have cameos. The songs -- some clever, some cheesy and pop-ish -- are by Oscar winners Alan Menken ("The Little Mermaid," "Beauty and the Beast") and Stephen Schwartz ("Pocahontas," "The Hunchback of Notre Dame").
This is a film Walt himself would have been proud of, a family flick that's marvelously gratifying no matter what your age.
Grade: B+
Rated PG, a little scariness, some very mild innuendo
1 hr., 47 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.



This item has 10 comments
November 23, 2007 at 1:36 am
Eric, in the newsletter, you said it was:
"ENCHANTED"
Grade: B+
Rated PG for a lot of harsh profanity, plenty of horror violence and some blood
I thought that sounded a bit much for a Disney film. Glad to see it's a little different here in the permanent review. =)
November 23, 2007 at 6:33 am
I liked most of it, except for the lone "chipmunk excrement" joke. That was bad enough in the 'Alvin and the Chipmunks' teaser. It stood out like a sore thumb in this mostly tasteful, delightful film.
November 23, 2007 at 8:25 am
Why do movies always think farts are funny? In real life they aren't, usually its either uncomfortable and you pretend not to hear it (like when an old lady farts in the grocery store line in front of you). I think movie-goers should strike to remove flatulence from films!
November 23, 2007 at 8:43 am
I went to this with a group of friends and all our kids (2 girls and 12 boys) and the moms enjoyed themselves quite a bit more than the kids. It's certainly clean enough to take your kids to, but the kids get bored during the slow parts. (Patrick Dempsey is talking = slow part.) Amy Adams is unbelievable and I'm feeling a strong need to see Junebug now.
December 6, 2007 at 3:09 am
I thought the movie was very good and original. Amy Adams should be added to your list of beautiful Hollywood women.
December 9, 2007 at 10:56 pm
I very much liked this movie. I was laughing like a madwoman for a good portion of the show. There were a couple of things I didn't really particularly like. I wasn't a huge fan of the squirrel-in-the-pants move in Central Park, for one. Although that hardly registers as a serious offense.
One of the only thing's I'd change about this movie is the following:
In the trailers, it showed Giselle as a cartoon falling down the well, and then immediately popping up the sewer-hole as a three-dimensional Amy Adams. I liked that. So although the scene with the underside of the sewer-hole WAS pretty cool, I liked how our first three-dimensional view of her is as she's seeing NYC for the very first time.
January 16, 2008 at 1:29 pm
I very much loved the movie. The romantic ball scene actually left me dreaming for a few days. I read somewhere there will be a second movie. If its so I hope they dont spoil it!
March 12, 2008 at 4:51 pm
I think this movie is enjoyable in many ways. It's cute, clean, and funny. I do like that it gets away from the cookie-cutter theme of "boy is hero who saves the girl" and "love just happens overnight." Love isn't perfect, and neither is life. Bad things happen, but that doesn't mean you can't have a happy ending. That's what I got from this movie.
April 2, 2008 at 5:11 am
For me the singing got to me, but PIP OMG!!! I was half sleep when the pip poop scene came in, call me uncooth or call me common, but I laughed so hard my nose actually began to bleed. My daughter kept playing the part over and over again and each time I found it absolutely HILARIOUS!!! Come on people we have enough things to make us put frown wrinkles in our foreheads, but think about, if you were scared as badly as poor little PIP, you would do the same thing. I'm sorry, it's been three days later and I still find myself chuckling and sometimes absolutely laughing out loud when I think of that part. I wish I could have it on my desktop whenever I needed a pick-me-up.
October 26, 2009 at 3:03 pm
I absolutely adored this movie. The only thing I'd change is that Idina Menzel is in this movie, and did not sing!