Eric D. Snider

Nobody Knows (Japanese)

Movie Review

Nobody Knows (Japanese)

by Eric D. Snider

Grade: A-

Released: February 4, 2005

 

Directed by:

Cast:

The horror of "Nobody Knows" descended upon me later, when the film was over and I was considering its effects. It is the very definition of "haunting," in that it has a strong impact in the viewing, but an even stronger one in the contemplating.

Loosely based on a true story, it begins with Keiko Fukushima (one-named actress You) moving into a small apartment with her 12-year-old son Akira (Yuya Yagira). She checks in with the husband-and-wife landlord team, exchanges pleasantries, and assures them Akira is her only child, so they needn't worry about noise or clutter. The landlords are happy.

Then the Fukushimas unpack their suitcases and reveal two stowaways: Keiko's other children, 5-year-old Yuki (Momoko Shimizu) and Shigeru (Hiei Kimura), about the same age. A fourth child, a girl named Kyoko (Ayu Kitaura) around 10, arrives by train later that night and is secreted into the apartment where the family of five will now live, three of them hiding, Anne Frank-style, from the world.

Mom is a sad case. She maintains a playful, easy relationship with the children, reminding Yuki and especially the energetic Shigeru of the importance of staying quiet and never leaving the apartment. They do not seem unhappy by the restrictions; probably this is life as they've always known it, bouncing from one apartment to another as Mom bounces from one low-level job to another. We gather that each of the children has a different father -- Akira is on a first-name basis with a few of them, who work in various menial jobs around town -- and that Keiko has never been married. She is flighty and silly, coming home very late one night, drunk, and waking up the kids so they can eat sushi with her. She thinks it sounds fun; the kids just want to sleep.

Keiko begins to be away for long periods of time, always leaving enough cash behind for Akira to run the household and buy groceries. Her absences grow longer and longer, her stays at home shorter and shorter, and finally she stops coming home altogether. She has abandoned her children.

Akira and Kyoko become the family's "parents," washing the dinner dishes while they discuss Shigeru's reluctance to eat his vegetables, Akira doing the shopping and errands while Kyoko tends to the younger children at home. None of them go to school, and they can't tell the police of their plight for fear of being split up into different foster homes. Besides, the situation doesn't strike them as dire. Mom left some money and continues to send cash now and then from her new home, wherever that is. Akira has grown accustomed to being the adult in the family; all that Mom's disappearance has done is make it official.

But you can only do something unnatural for so long before nature rebels. Akira is a young boy on the bring of adolescence. He goes through a phase where he befriends some trouble-making local boys simply because he wants the normalcy of childhood. He invites them over to play video games, pushing his siblings out of the way, shirking his family duties simply by being what he's supposed to be: a kid. In one heartbreaking scene, he takes Yuki into the city because it's her birthday, the little girl realizing Mom probably isn't coming back but so used to being neglected that now it just rolls off her. In another scene, Akira finds a baseball in the park and hits it with a stick, that simple childlike pastime bringing him unimaginable joy. And then it is back home to the kids.

The money runs out eventually. The electricity and water are shut off. The children make friends with a local girl named Saki (Hane Kan), a sad waif who sympathizes with their loneliness, though they withhold the complete details of their situation from her, and it looks like she will be of some help to them. But they don't need another minor looking out for them. They need parents.

Japanese filmmaker Hirokazu Koreeda ("After Life") shot "Nobody Knows" in chronological order and took a year to do it, which means the children age, almost imperceptibly, over the course of the film. More noticeable is the gradual descent of the little family from neatness to squalor as they slowly lose sight of the real world, though even there, Koreeda avoids melodrama. I didn't even notice until afterward that at some point, the children stop keeping the secret their mother gave them (that there are four of them in the apartment, rather than one) and start going outside boldly, probably because they have realized that the world doesn't care about them anyway.

The film ends with a sense of hope, but also with a sense that the hope is false. The young actors give such disciplined, believable performances as to be heart-wrenching -- not because they overdo the emotional aspects or play to our sympathies, but precisely because they DON'T do that. The children remain so stoic, their determination barely masking their youthful innocence, that we can't bear to think of their story having an unhappy ending.

Grade: A-

Rated PG-13, a couple mild sexual references, a little mild profanity, mature themes

2 hrs., 21 min.; Japanese with subtitles

Stumble It!

This item has 7 comments

  1. Joel says:

    I just saw this film, and "haunting" is a good way to describe it. The children's performances were so incredibly sincere that I felt almost voyeuristic for watching it. There is one scene when the kids are playing on a merry-go-round in the nearby park that I found myself laughing out loud with glee along with them--they were so happy just to play out in the open.

    The score is done mostly with ukulele and guitar, and evokes the emotional highs and lows of the film. It's not just a sad movie. It's definitely worth seeing.

  2. Julie says:

    I want to know how the children are doing today? (whoever is alive)

  3. Kristine says:

    This movie stayed with me for days, which is amazing with today's blockbusters. I found myself also, on the emotions of these children, highs and sad lows. WONDERFUL need to see.

  4. gillian says:

    SPOILERS

    i agree with the rest of the commenters this moving was touching and it sowed me that tough they had nothing they overcame it all.the movie was also very hard to watch while crying ecspecially when the yougest daughter passes

  5. blitzonic says:

    Re: "I want to know how the children are doing today? (whoever is alive)"

    After the film release revived public interest in the actual accident, many new details have been added to the requisite wikipedia entry (translated from Japanese sources):-
    http://tinyurl.com/mmyr9q

    Also found an old webletter Q&A by the Consulate General of Japan at Chicago, circa 2005-6:-
    Q: Just viewed "Nobody Knows," a true story of four Japanese children abandoned by their young mother, and raised by their oldest brother. Very tragic story, which was hard to believe would happen in Japan. Whatever happened to them?
    - Jean Inouye
    A: The actual incident that inspired the film happened in 1988 and was known as "The Affair of the Four Abandoned Children in Nishi-Sugamo." Interestingly, searching for this phrase yielded only movie reviews of Nobody Knows (Dare mo shiranai). It seems the movie has come to overshadow the original events that inspired it.
    In fact, the true story is perhaps sadder than the movie. The second daughter was actually killed by two friends of the son, who was indicted for bodily injury resulting in death. The court found that the two friends were mainly responsible for the murder, so they were taken to a reformatory. The son was placed in a school for physically and mentally handicapped children, but it is unclear what has happened to him. The mother was sentenced to three years' imprisonment. The two girls were initially sent to the same school as the son, but after her release from prison, the mother regained custody of them. Beyond this, we're not sure what happened.
    http://tinyurl.com/nzsmd3

  6. Dom says:

    Watching Nobody Knows the movie was MINDBLOWING. Especially when SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

    Saki prostituded herself to earn some money for Akira and the death of the cure and innocent Yuki and how she is buried at near the airport. It's a great movie and the messages really stick into the mind for a while. I just wish one day i go back to Japan to meet Hanae Kan.

  7. adrianna says:

    I have been watching many Asian films lately , better than
    American movies.
    spoiler alert!!
    but what I don't understand why everyone is saying
    it's based off a true story, in the beginning it says,this movie
    is entirely fictional. maybe, it seems like it s based off that
    but thats like saying many murder movies made in America are
    true stories because anything can be created and anything
    can happen.

    but it was an amazing movie, a little dry and slow.
    I wish he could have gotten a hold of the mom and
    yell and her and let her know that yuki died.

    I would also recommend owl and the sparrow, a great vietemnese
    film based off neglect but has a great ending.

Subscription Center

Eric D. Snider's "Snide Remarks"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly humor column, "Snide Remarks." For more information, go here.

Subscribe

Eric D. Snider's "In the Dark"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly movie-review e-zine. For more information on it, go here.

Subscribe
 
Come read about baseball and web development at www.jeffjsnider.com | Diamond Clarity Chart