Robin Hood
Movie Review
"Robin Hood"
Review by Eric D. Snider
Grade: C
Rating: PG-13
Released: Friday, May 14, 2010
Directed by:
Cast:
A great many thing are wrong with Ridley Scott's "Robin Hood" -- it's too long, too drab, and too tedious, to name a few -- but let's start with its title. Just as Tim Burton's "Alice in Wonderland" sounded like a remake but was actually a sequel, Scott's "Robin Hood" is not a retelling of the jolly adventure story but a prequel to it. It's "The Origins of Robin Hood." The film is 140 minutes long, and it ends at the part where things are just starting to get interesting. The story that comes after this one -- that sounds fun!
But not this one. Ugh, what a load this is. It came from a screenplay by Ethan Reiff and Cyrus Voris that retold the familiar story from the sheriff of Nottingham's point of view. Naturally, once the screenplay was purchased, the Hollywood wizards completely changed everything about it that was original or unique and hired the prolific rewriter Brian Helgeland ("L.A. Confidential," "Mystic River") to turn it into "Gladiator." Tellingly, the sheriff -- originally the main character -- is barely in the film.
Heck, even Robin Hood is barely in the film. Played by Russell Crowe, he's Robin Longstride most of the time, and impersonating someone else the rest of the time. (This version of "Robin Hood" is like a version of "Batman" that ends with Bruce Wayne deciding to become Batman.) Having fought alongside King Richard (Danny Huston) in the Crusades for 10 years, he's now on his way back to England, in A.D. 1199, when a fellow soldier named Robert Loxley (Douglas Hodge) is killed in a French ambush. Loxley's dying wish is that Robin return his (Loxley's) sword to his father back home in Nottingham.
Well, guess who Loxley's wife (now widow) is? None other than Marian (Cate Blanchett), who is not a Maid but a Lady. And guess who Loxley's father is? A blind old man -- played by Max von Sydow, who played a soldier returning from the Crusades in Ingmar Bergman's "The Seventh Seal" -- who happens to have known Robin's father before he (Robin's father) abandoned him years ago.
For reasons too embarrassing and contrived to relate here, Robin Longstride is compelled to pretend to be Loxley's son and Marian's husband, to fool the sheriff (Matthew Macfadyen). Yes, this version of "Robin Hood" is like a romantic comedy where two people who don't get along at first are forced to work together.
Meanwhile, Richard's brother, Prince John (Oscar Isaac), is whoring it up with a French tart and embarrassing the Queen Mother (Eileen Atkins). In charge of the kingdom while Richard is off killing Muslims, John raises taxes, which is necessary because his brother's Muslim-killing war is expensive. In Nottingham, there's a new friar named Tuck (Mark Addy) who plays no significant role whatsoever but is here because the movie is called "Robin Hood" and there damn well better be a Friar Tuck in it.
And what of Robin's merry men? Well, there are three of them -- Little John (Kevin Durand), Will Scarlet (Scott Grimes), and Allan A'Dayle (Alan Doyle) -- and they are generally convivial, if not merry, per se. But they're the only ones. Oh, and Prince John, I guess. He's pretty upbeat. He isn't evil or greedy, though, like you were expecting. Just sort of weaselly and in-over-his-head, and keen to ignore the wise counsel of royal adviser William Marshal (William Hurt).
So if the sheriff is neutered and Prince John is merely inept, who are the bad guys? The French, duh. English-born turncoat Godfrey (Mark Strong) pretends to work with Prince John but secretly advises France's King Philip (Jonathan Zaccai), who's planning an invasion.
Such a crowded, busy movie! And so somber, except when it takes a moment, here and there, to pander to the lowest common denominator with a broad joke or two. Ridley Scott shoots the action scenes the way he always shoots action scenes -- competently, energetically -- but without any life. His frequent collaborator, Mr. Crowe, is likewise lifeless, as he often is in action roles. (Put him in something more character-based, like "The Insider," or even last year's "State of Play," and you can't take your eyes off him.) Cate Blanchett is luminous in a thankless role. And what's up with the absurd finale, where suddenly everyone is a warrior? And what the eff does any of this have to do with Robin Hood?
This is a film with no distinguishing characteristics. If it mugged you in an alley, you would only be able to tell the police, "Well, it was two hours and 20 minutes long, and it had Russell Crowe, and there were a lot of bows and arrows, and I think the Prince John character was kind of fun, sometimes." The police artist would do a composite sketch, and they'd show it on the news, and everyone would say, "Wow, that looks a lot like 'Gladiator.' Are you sure it wasn't 'Gladiator' that mugged you? Has anyone seen 'Gladiator' lately?" And you'd say no, this was similar to "Gladiator," only more average, less fun, and slightly shorter.
Grade: C
Rated PG-13, a lot of violence, nothing terribly graphic, brief sexual content, brief partial nudity
2 hrs., 20 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.




This item has 17 comments
May 14, 2010 at 1:37 am
The last paragraph of this review absolutely killed me.
May 14, 2010 at 2:50 am
Robin Hood and his band of convivial men! Love it :)
May 14, 2010 at 7:51 am
movie mugged...love it
May 14, 2010 at 9:19 am
One of the Convival Men (Alan Doyle) is the front man for my favourite band Great Big Sea, so I'm going to see this to support Alan. But it's good to know I'll need to bring a book. (Fangirl plug for the band) you should all check out the band, they're a folk band that uses Newfoundland folk music as a basis for the rock they play.
May 14, 2010 at 11:55 am
I still think the best Robin Hood ever was a fox.
May 14, 2010 at 2:02 pm
Joey: let's also not forget Cleese in Time Bandits. Not that I'm disputing. The fox probably wins.
May 14, 2010 at 4:15 pm
Wasn't excited about the midnight showing, went anyways cause my friends went. Didn't know it would be 2 1/2 hours. Didn't know it was a prequel, and Eric nailed this blah movie with the perfect arrow shot movie review.
May 14, 2010 at 4:46 pm
Gladiator is my favorite movie. Does that mean I will like this one, even though you didn't? Also Hans Zimmer is my hero and his protege is billed as composer (read: Hans did the music and let someone else take credit, as he tends to do). Does the music stack up?
May 14, 2010 at 6:14 pm
Eric liked Gladiator too. He gave it an A (his highest grade. He doesn't do A+'s): http://www.ericdsnider.com/movies/gladiator/
May 14, 2010 at 6:32 pm
So the character named Allan A'Dayle is played by an actor named Alan Doyle? Me thinks the casting director is having some fun here.
May 14, 2010 at 6:53 pm
Do you suppose Alan Doyle was cast simply because his real name sounded so similar to his character name?
May 16, 2010 at 1:50 am
hahaha. last paragraph = so funny.
and, yeah...agree with other post: best robin hood was a fox ;)
May 16, 2010 at 9:56 am
It's more likely Alan Doyle was cast as Allan A'Dayle because he's worked with Crowe on musical projects, and so playing a minstrel/warrior wasn't too far off for him. And the Newfoundland accent wasn't too far off of a British one, so that helped.
P.S. If you liked the music the "Convival Men" played and sang in the movie, you'll like Great Big Sea. Those songs are classic Alan Doyle and Great Big Sea.
May 25, 2010 at 12:10 pm
Dare I say that Gladiator wasn't exactly the most original movie to begin with? I remember when it came out I wanted to call it either "Braveicus" or "Spartiheart" as all of it's plot points came from either Braveheart or Sparticus.
And considering Eric brought it up, this Robin Hood has more in common with Batman Begins than anything else, except for, obviously, Gladiator.
I do have to disagree with the assesment of Friar Tuck, though.
Spoiler alert! (Not that many will give a darn)
He's the one who gets Robin to commit his first crime against the state by robbing the church grain, which, considering this is "Robin Hood Begins", is at least somewhat important.
May 29, 2010 at 7:07 am
Will see this just to see Alan Doyle. He is an amazing talent.
June 7, 2010 at 1:15 pm
Gladiator was a waste of time...I was angered (though /i shouldn't have been; I{ understand how the Academy Awards work) when "Gladiaor" was chosen over "Pollock"({ a superior movie).It did not require a great deal acting,though Russell Crowe is an excellent actor (ie:"A Beautiful Mind").
However, my comment is about "Robin Hood". It would've been historically (although there were at least 20 people over a 70 year period called "Robin Hood") more credible had Marion been identified as a priestess in the old religion, hence the title, "Maid"(having nothing to do with Norman England's sense of social standing, nor virginity). Also, the term "Robin O'Hood" might indicate the character's standing in the old religion.
My favorite Robin Hood movie is "Robin and Marion" with Sean Connery.
So now, I have revealed myself as not only opinionated, but the master of parenthetical comments.
June 29, 2010 at 1:37 am
I believe that in order to receive the title of "master of parenthetical comments", you have to use them correctly.