It is my opinion that "TMNT" is as good a movie about teenage mutant ninja turtles as there can possibly be. The protagonists are mutated turtles who have learned martial arts, have grown to the size of adult humans, and have learned English. I really think B- is as good as you're going to get with this premise.
"TMNT" is aimed at two audiences: 12-year-old boys, and grown men who loved the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles in the early 1990s, when they were 12-year-old boys. I did not pay attention to the TMNT phenomenon until much later, when I watched the 1990 feature film and was impressed with how bad it was. What I called "bad," though -- lame jokes, hole-filled plot, clownish acting, etc. -- was apparently what many fans LIKED about it. So take it for what it's worth when I say the new "TMNT" film is a lot like its predecessors.
One way it's better, however, is that it's animated. It never made sense to make live-action films about characters who never looked remotely convincing when played by actors in rubber suits. "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" began life as a comic book, then became an animated TV series; it should have stayed animated. You accept a lot more simplicity, silliness, and just plain dumbness with a cartoon than you do with live-action.
The new film is computer animated, and it looks fantastic. The movement is sleek and fluid, nearly as much so as in a Pixar film. Writer/director Kevin Munroe (his first feature film) and his animators make full use of the technology to give "TMNT" action sequences and visual effects that would be expensive or impossible with real actors and sets.
The story picks up a few years after the last film left off, which means our heroes probably aren't even teenagers anymore, though they're definitely still mutant ninja turtles. They all look the same, so you have to memorize which one has which color headband. Leonardo (blue headband, voice of James Arnold Taylor) has been living in a jungle for a year, sent by Splinter (Mako Iwamatsu) for some training. Back home in New York, Donatello (purple, Mitchell Whitfield) and Michelangelo (orange, Mikey Kelley) are finding non-ninja ways of making a living, while Raphael (red, Nolan North) has assumed de facto leadership of the group and spends his nights as an anonymous crime-fighter called the Nightwatcher.
Then Leonardo comes home, and just in time: A sinister man named Max Winters (Patrick Stewart) is using magic to reanimate ancient statues, which he sends out to collect a batch of ugly monsters, for which he has additional nefarious purposes in mind. Do not trust a man who brings statues to life, and especially do not trust him if he uses the statues as monster-fetchers. You can take that one to the bank. But before the turtles can fight Max Winters and his evil horde, they must repair the rift that runs among themselves. Only as a united team can they save the day.
The action scenes are lively enough, and taken for what it is -- a cartoon about crime-fighting reptiles -- it's fine as Saturday-matinee entertainment. The turtles still make corny semi-jokes like, "Why skate a half-pipe when you can skate a sewer pipe?!," and human friends April (Sarah Michelle Gellar) and Casey (Chris Evans) are still on hand to get in the way. If you liked the previous TMNT films, then I can't imagine why you wouldn't like this one, too.
Grade: B-
Rated PG, cartoon violence
1 hr., 27 min.
Copyright © Eric D. Snider.
This work may not be transmitted via the Internet, nor reproduced in any other way, without written consent from Eric D. Snider.
This item has 10 comments
March 26, 2007 at 12:43 pm
I enjoyed those movies when I was younger, and I'm a girl. Not for the plausibility or amazing storytelling, but for the sort of silly friendliness of it all. Loathed the 3rd one, though. (On a tangent: This movie's set after the 1st & 2nd movies and pretty much pretends the 3rd one never happened. A wise choice, I think).
March 26, 2007 at 12:45 pm
I meant to add "which wasn't much a part of the movie" right after "amazing storytelling."
March 26, 2007 at 4:06 pm
I completely second Cafe_Au_Lait. I got dragged to the first movie knowing nothing about the series-- I wasn't even with friends, I was with my kinda-adopted older brother and my "actual" little sister. I think he was taking us out as a favor to my mom and I was hating them for it... when we came out of the theater I was totally in love with TMNT. It was SO much fun. Not so big on plot, but lots of fun. heh.
March 26, 2007 at 6:27 pm
I saw it and liked it. The Leo vs. Raph fight was the highlight of the entire movie for me. I hope they keep the (relatively) more serious tone for future movies, rather than the campy goofiness of the cartoon.
March 30, 2007 at 5:22 am
Yes, girls, now women, have enjoyed TMNT in the past and I think I might enjoy this movie as well. I'm tired of almost every review referring to TMNT as something boys/guys grew up with and loved.
March 30, 2007 at 11:24 am
I think "Crime-fighting Reptiles" is going to make it big as a band name.
March 31, 2007 at 8:49 am
I remember watching TMNT when I was a little girl. My favorite episode was TMNT: the Case of the Killer Pizzas, because they end up eating the bad um... foods at the end.
Whew... now that I think about it, that's pretty disturbing.
March 31, 2007 at 3:16 pm
Yup... part of the girl-crowd that liked TMNT growing up. Took my husband and 9-month old daughter to see this. It was decent. Most of the dialogue was pretty good (some lines were super-corny). I actually didn't care for the Raph-Leo storyline that ate up most of the movie... I mean, hasn't some sort of Raph-Leo storyline eaten up every other movie? There's two other turtles y'know, writers.
Still, it was fun, I liked SMG as April and that Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon chick as Karai. Hope they make another one soon.
April 6, 2007 at 9:00 am
I join the 'girl-crowd'... I watched TMNT, and collected merchandise. Saying it only appeals to boys; for shame, Eric! I also watched Transformers, GI Joe, SilverHawks, ThunderCats... you get the idea. I haven't seen the movie yet, but I'm taking my son *and* daughter to go see it just for the rompy, campy fun.
August 23, 2007 at 6:53 pm
eh fine review, even though you seem to really dislike the Turtles.
Still the "movie" could have used some decapitations and a better plot, damn I hate the 13 monsters legend cr*p