Eric D. Snider

Up in the Air

Movie Review

Up in the Air

by Eric D. Snider

Grade: B+

Released: December 11, 2009

 

Directed by:

Cast:

It's bad enough being laid off from your job. Imagine getting the news from a suit-wearing stranger you've never seen before who was flown in at the company's expense just to fire you and a bunch of your coworkers. With all that money they spent paying a drone to do their dirty work, they could have kept you on an extra couple days. Jerks.

Such "outsourced termination" companies really exist, and as you might imagine, business is booming these days. "Up in the Air," based on Walter Kirn's 2001 novel, takes on a new relevance now. Adapted and directed by Jason Reitman ("Thank You for Smoking," "Juno"), it addresses the uncertainties of the current economy without becoming mired in them -- it's still a very, very funny movie, too, with a timeless message: You may not always have your job, so make sure it's not the only thing in your life.

The star firer at Career Transition Corporation is Ryan Bingham (George Clooney), and he loves his work. The company is based in Omaha, but Ryan prides himself on only being home a few days out of the year. For him, "home" is the road: airport lounges, airplane cabins, rental cars, hotels. He's good at firing people cleanly, in a way that minimizes the drama. Get in, break the news, get out, fly to the next city.

Ryan has two sisters, one of whom is about to get married, but he mostly views family as a burden. His loyalties are to particular airlines and hotels. His goal in life is to rack up 10 million frequent flyer miles on American Airlines. He's occasionally hired to give motivational seminars, the message of which is that personal relationships only drag you down. ("What kind of f*****-up message is that?!" someone finally says, vocalizing what the viewer has been thinking all along.)

Into this peaceful, unexamined existence come two interruptions, one welcome and one not. First is Alex Goran (Vera Farmiga), a fellow frequent flyer who shares Ryan's love of non-commitment to other human beings and who is glad to have one-night stands whenever they happen to be in the same city at the same time. Surely there is no danger that either of them will fall in love and want something deeper, right?

The other intruder is also a woman, Natalie Keener (Anna Kendrick), a young new hotshot at Career Transition Corporation who has some bright ideas about streamlining the firing process. Ironically, Ryan's own job is now in danger, and he must take Natalie on the road with him to show her how it's done. He scoffs at her inexperience with air travel -- her bulky carry-ons, her neck pillows -- while she quickly deduces that Ryan lives in "a cocoon of self-banishment."

The role of a good-looking, charming, 40-ish bachelor who loves being unattached was tailor-made for George Clooney, so it's no wonder he's effortlessly funny and engaging in it. Ryan is eventually forced to reconsider his priorities and learn some valuable life lessons, but apart from one trite moment where he's giving a seminar and has an epiphany midway through it (how often has that cliche been used?), the film avoids the predictable route. Indeed, there are a few honest surprises, some turns in the story that you would not have expected.

Through all the comedy is a timely undercurrent of melancholy, embodied in montages of nameless people reacting to the news of their firing. I admire this tactic, and it improves the film tremendously. It would have been callous to make a film about people getting fired, in today's economic climate, without acknowledging the reality of it. One of the laid-off victims, played by Zack Galifianakis, speaks up when Ryan gives him the axe: "Who the f*** are you?" Ryan, serving as narrator, says, "Excellent question. Who the f*** am I?" By the end of the film, he's figured out the answer. As "Fight Club" told us a decade ago, you are not your job. And if you are, you shouldn't be.

Grade: B+

Rated R, a little nudity, some sexual dialogue, some harsh profanity

1 hr., 49 min.

Stumble It!

This item has 9 comments

  1. Ampersand says:

    I saw this film a few weeks ago at a press screening and liked it a lot, so I'm glad you gave it a good grade. I found it interesting that most of the people in the firing montage were actual people who had been fired, not actors. Reitman recruited them by placing newspaper ads looking for people to appear in a documentary about job loss.

  2. milkshake says:

    I saw this movie last year just one week after being fired on moment's notice without severance. It is a great movie, darkly funny too, and Clooney is in his best. But it ought to be said that the ex-employees are not necessarily powerless and desolate - one becomes delightfully free to fight right back and the best part of it is that organisation that did this to you has absolutely nothing to threaten you with anymore. (First you send in EPA, then OSHA, then fire-marshals, then you report your ex-boss for embezzlement... and when all is done you collate the reports of these government investigation - which so far cost you nothing - and you build a discrimination + whistleblower wrongful dismissal case)

  3. Rob D. says:

    I liked this movie a lot. I had no idea that some of the people that got fired were really people who got fired- lol. I was thinking that a few of them seemed real and like a documentary. That was a nice touch.

  4. Peter says:

    I think it was okay.

    Enjoyable. Not bad. But not great.

  5. Adam X says:

    2009: a sucky, sucky year for movies.

    I went to this movie with hope. Probably only because I enjoyed Michael Clayton and I like how understated George C. can be.

    This movie's empty though. So boring.

    I walked out a little over half way through, so what can I say.

    All I can say is the first half is extremely boring. It REALLY tries to be cute! (but it's not)

    Regarding the people getting fired: so unrealistic. People aren't like that. (Yeah, yeah, I know many of these people were 'real people' .... real people saying what they WISHED they'd said when they were fired in the first place.)

    Dumb movie.

    Oh yeah - and the lead actor suffered from a case of don't-try-too-hard and don't-want-too-much.

    It's the school of cool.

    Fine. He's cool, for sure. But if he doesn't care, then why should I care? I didn't care (that he might be losing his way of life).

    Lame.

  6. Arnie says:

    A sequel to Erica Jong's Fear Of Flying, this is a charicature of the dynamic of a fear of intimacy, but with an inherent ambivalence generated by existential angst, including feelings and fear of isolation.

  7. Baz says:

    Terrible film. First time in my life that I actually wanted to get up half way through the film and walk out. 2 hours of my life that I will never get back.

  8. Tom C. says:

    VERY VERY VERY BAD

  9. Hawaiian says:

    As a frequent flier and road warrior with almost 2 million miles logged, I actually appreciated this film. There are so many different thought processes that a true road warrior goes through when making their way through an airport, rental car and hotel stays.

    Very entertaining movie... What happens on the road, stays on the road!


Subscription Center

Eric D. Snider's "Snide Remarks"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly humor column, "Snide Remarks." For more information, go here.

Subscribe

Eric D. Snider's "In the Dark"

This is to join the mailing list for Eric's weekly movie-review e-zine. For more information on it, go here.

Subscribe
 
This site created and maintained by Jeff J. Snider | Diamond Clarity Chart