Home Blog The latest in incoherence

The latest in incoherence

24

Someone has posted a comment on my review of “The Golden Compass” at Film.com that is so incoherent, you’d think it had been written by Tim Nasson. Here’s what “WALLYONE” had to say:

Golden Compass is rather well put together, like one might expect a refreshing new candy. Be mindful the picture is aimed at the 13-15 year age group (which might explain why Mr Snider’s review has a bi-polaric bearish overview which concludes with best paragraph (of which I heartily and bi-polaric concur)) The picture would appear to be enjoyed by a mature audience through that 13-15 wonderment/confirming age, where at least you could argue/disagree with authority (in at least on your alternate growth world stage). Overviews should also take note the repeated efforts to sell the (untitled (at least to this reviewer) follow-on well wrapped candy for which the production costs will much less because at least half of the story is already in the can. The Dakota Richards heroine character (Lyra) has been well set, while the Kidman (Mrs. Coulter) is likely to suprise in development(s) based on the slapping of her soul and unsaid/unheard lines to unbuilt bridges. One of the most confirming scenes was Lyra’s use of Mrs. Coulter’s fly to strike back at the adult with their own toy (13-15 behavior). thankyou

Translation? Anyone?

24 COMMENTS

  1. My guess is that the author is 13, has read the books, thinks he or she has some really deep thoughts to share, and thinks that as long as something is bizarre and/or confusing it is automatically deep. So obviously it is a reincarnated 13i-year-old Stanley Kubrick.

  2. I think WALLYONE has confused The Golden Compass with Willy Wonka.

    I was surprised myself by a weirdly positive review of The Golden Compass in the Church Times, an Anglican newspaper. (Review here: http://www.churchtimes.co.uk/content.asp?id=48271 )

    Perhaps the reviewer’s tongue is firmly in his cheek when he writes, “Given the removal of God-talk from the screenplay, I am tempted to see the Magisterium as representing truculent atheists who are intolerant of any expressions of religious belief and blind to a vision of heaven, and see human beings as consisting of nothing but an assortment of chemicals you can buy at the local pharmacy. ”

    I’ll have to check to see if they have a review of Equus — or “a nice movie about a boy and his horse” as some might see it. (“If you liked ‘Equus,’ which not try ‘My Friend Flicka.'”)

  3. “based on the slapping of her soul.” That’s amazing. I must find ways to use that phrase in my daily conversation.

  4. I’m going to guess that English is not this person’s native language, and he’s written something that made sense in his own language then ran it through something like babelfish to come up with the English and then posted that.

    But, if that were true, how did he read Eric’s review in English in the first place?

    Drugs, must be drugs.

  5. I thought the same thing as KMD, but it’s too clever sounding to be from babelfish. Like “bipolaristic bearish” is meant to be a pun and I can’t imagine a program translating something that subtle. It’s got to be someone who thinks they are smart when they aren’t, or it could be English is their second language but they are a fairly advanced student of English. Thus they are incoherent because they don’t understand the simple nuances of the language, but they understand how to sound clever and witty. I know I’ve met people like this who never mastered the basics of the language but understand esoteric concepts of the language. It makes for very amusing conversations.

    Also, is that panda supposed to be the bipolar bear?

  6. This is from a non-native English speaker. Possibly from a speaker of a SE Asian or Germanic/east European language. Either that or a bipolar bear.

  7. I was more impressed with the juxtaposition of the terms “mature” and “13-15 years old”. I think we’ve at least managed to pin down the author’s age.

  8. An addendum: I just read the other two posts. Why does the third post say “Ditto (for the first comment only)?” I’m pretty sure a native English speaker doesn’t have the faintest clue what that comment is saying, and would never want to be associated with it even if they really liked the movie.

  9. These sound like my thoughts during REM sleep after a long, long, late night of cramming for finals. You know, in that “Schizophrenic Humanities” degree I am working on.

  10. As someone who actually has been diagnosed as bipolar, I think his use of the word “bipolar” is hilarious. IT ALSO MAKES ME ANGRY! And sad. So very, very sad.

    English is definitely not his native language, but I’m leaning towards one of them Dutchy-Norwegiany languages as his first. Or possibly Keyword-spamish. Did he include a URL that would clue us in?

  11. That speech/comment reminds me of this 15 year old Dutch kid I know. He talks just like that! Eric, you could take that rambling, and turn it into an lolcat on icanhascheezburger. It’d be a big hit. Especially if it was a polar bear!

  12. I think it is a 13-15 year old who thinks he/she is extremely clever, but really isn’t. You can’t fake intelligence.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here